Circuit Design: A Comprehensive Educational Resource

Circuit Design, Electrical Engineering, Integrated Circuit, EDA, Simulation, Verification, Prototyping, Design Software, Costs, Documentation

Circuit design is a multifaceted process that ranges from the creation of expansive electronic systems to the intricate arrangement

Read the original article here.

Introduction to Circuit Design

Circuit design, in the field of Electrical Engineering, is a multifaceted process that ranges from the creation of expansive electronic systems to the intricate arrangement of individual transistors within an integrated circuit. For simple circuits, a single designer might manage the entire process informally. However, as designs become more complex, particularly in modern integrated circuit design, collaborative teams employing systematic methodologies and sophisticated computer simulations are essential.

Within the realm of integrated circuit design automation, “circuit design” often pinpoints a specific stage in the design cycle. This stage focuses on generating the schematic diagrams of the integrated circuit, serving as a crucial bridge between the initial logic design phase and the subsequent physical design phase.

Integrated Circuit (IC): Also known as a microchip or chip, an integrated circuit is a set of electronic circuits on one small flat piece (or “chip”) of semiconductor material, normally silicon.

The Circuit Design Process

Traditional circuit design is a structured progression through several key stages, ensuring a design that meets requirements and is manufacturable.

1. Specification and Requirements Gathering

The process typically begins with defining the project’s scope and requirements. This often involves close communication with the client or stakeholders to understand their needs and expectations.

• Customer Liaison: Initial discussions to understand the desired functionality and performance of the circuit.
• Design Specification Document: A formal document outlining the project’s goals, technical requirements, and constraints. This document serves as the blueprint for the entire design process.

2. Technical Proposal

Based on the design specification, a technical proposal is developed. This proposal outlines the proposed solution, approach, and estimated resources required to meet the customer’s needs.

• Feasibility Study: Assessing the technical viability of the design and identifying potential challenges.
• Resource Estimation: Calculating the required time, personnel, and budget for the project.

3. Schematic Design and Synthesis

This stage involves the crucial step of translating the specifications into an abstract representation of the circuit.

• Schematic Circuit Diagram: A visual representation of the electronic circuit using symbols to denote components and connections. This is often done on paper or using Electronic Design Automation (EDA) software.
• Component Value Calculation: Determining the appropriate values for resistors, capacitors, inductors, and other components to achieve the desired circuit behavior under specified operating conditions.
• Mathematical Modeling: Utilizing mathematical equations and models to predict circuit performance and optimize component values.

4. Simulation and Verification

Before physically building the circuit, simulation plays a critical role in verifying the design’s correctness.

• Circuit Simulation: Using software tools to simulate the behavior of the designed circuit under various conditions. This helps identify potential flaws and optimize performance before prototyping.
• Design Verification: Ensuring that the designed circuit meets all the requirements outlined in the specification through simulation and analysis.

Simulation in Circuit Design: The process of using computer software to model and analyze the behavior of an electronic circuit before it is physically built. This allows designers to test and optimize their designs, identify potential issues, and reduce the need for costly and time-consuming physical prototyping. Common simulation tools include SPICE and its derivatives.

5. Prototyping and Testing

Once the design is simulated and verified, a physical prototype is built for real-world testing.

• Breadboarding or Prototyping: Constructing a temporary version of the circuit using a breadboard or other prototyping platforms to test its functionality.
• Testing against Specification: Rigorous testing of the prototype to ensure it performs as expected and meets the requirements defined in the specification document.
• Iterative Refinement: Identifying and rectifying any discrepancies or issues found during testing. This may involve modifying component values, circuit topology, or even revisiting earlier design stages.

6. Construction and Component Selection

After successful prototyping, the design moves towards final construction and component selection for mass production.

• Method of Construction: Choosing the appropriate manufacturing method, such as Printed Circuit Board (PCB) fabrication or integrated circuit manufacturing.
• Parts and Materials Selection: Selecting specific components and materials based on performance requirements, cost considerations, availability, and reliability.

7. Documentation and Manufacturing Preparation

Preparing comprehensive documentation and layout information for manufacturing is crucial for efficient production.

• Component and Layout Information: Creating detailed documentation including Bill of Materials (BOM), schematic diagrams, PCB layout files (Gerber files), and assembly instructions.
• Presentation to Draughtspersons and Layout Engineers: Communicating design details to specialized engineers responsible for creating manufacturing-ready artwork and layouts.
• Presentation to Mechanical Engineers: Collaborating with mechanical engineers for enclosure design, thermal management, and overall product integration.

8. Prototype Production and Type-Testing

Generating multiple prototypes and conducting rigorous type-testing is essential for ensuring product quality and compliance.

• Prototype Production: Manufacturing a small batch of prototypes based on the final design documentation.
• Type-Testing: Comprehensive testing of prototypes to verify compliance with customer requirements, industry standards, and regulatory guidelines. This may include environmental testing (temperature, humidity, vibration), electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) testing, and safety testing.

9. Final Approval and Manufacturing Drawings

The final stage involves obtaining approvals and finalizing manufacturing documentation for mass production.

• Signing and Approval of Manufacturing Drawings: Formal sign-off on all manufacturing documentation by relevant stakeholders, indicating the design is ready for production.
• Post-Design Services: Providing ongoing support, including addressing component obsolescence, design revisions, and handling manufacturing issues throughout the product lifecycle.

Specification: Defining the Design Requirements

The specification is the cornerstone of circuit design. It clearly articulates the what – the functionality the circuit must achieve – without dictating the how – the specific implementation details. This document is crucial for guiding the entire design process and ensuring the final product meets the customer’s expectations.

Key Elements of a Circuit Design Specification

• Functional Requirements: Defining the intended purpose and operations of the circuit. This includes specifying the input signals, desired output signals, and the relationship between them.
• Electrical Requirements: Detailing the electrical characteristics the circuit must adhere to.
  • Input Signals: Types of signals the circuit will receive (e.g., analog, digital, voltage levels, frequency range).
  • Output Signals: Types of signals the circuit must generate (e.g., voltage levels, current drive capability, signal characteristics).
  • Power Supply Requirements: Available power supply voltages and current limits.
  • Power Consumption Limits: Maximum allowable power consumption for the circuit.
• Physical Parameters: Specifying physical constraints and environmental conditions the circuit must withstand.
  • Size and Weight: Dimensional limitations and weight restrictions.
  • Environmental Conditions: Operating temperature range, humidity resistance, moisture resistance, vibration tolerance, and acceleration tolerance.
  • Thermal Output: Maximum allowable heat dissipation.
• Performance Metrics: Defining quantifiable performance targets.
  • Speed: Operating frequency or data processing rate.
  • Accuracy: Precision and tolerance levels.
  • Efficiency: Power efficiency and energy consumption.
  • Reliability: Expected lifespan and failure rates.
• Testing and Verification Procedures: Outlining the tests and criteria for verifying that the design meets the specifications.
• Regulatory Compliance: Specifying relevant industry standards and regulations the circuit must comply with (e.g., safety standards, EMC regulations).

Evolving Specifications and Design Creep

The specification is not always static. As the design progresses, designers may need to revisit and refine the specification based on new insights or challenges.

• Iterative Specification Refinement: Adjusting the specification throughout the design process to accommodate design progress, new information, or evolving customer needs. This may involve tightening certain specifications or adding new tests to ensure robust design verification.
• Customer Approval for Changes: Any modifications to the original customer specifications must be reviewed and approved by the customer to maintain alignment and prevent misunderstandings.
• Design Creep: A situation that can arise from poorly defined initial specifications or inadequate communication with the client. It results in a circuit that either exceeds the necessary functionality or fails to meet the core requirements.
• Managing Design Creep: Establishing clear and realistic initial expectations, maintaining open communication with the client throughout the design process, and diligently managing specification changes are crucial to avoid design creep.
• Flexibility and Future-Proofing: While avoiding design creep, it is good practice to maintain some flexibility in the design and consider potential future requirements. Incorporating spare capacity or modular design elements can make it easier to adapt the circuit to evolving needs later on.

Design: From Abstract Plan to Physical Implementation

The design stage is the core of the circuit creation process, transforming the abstract specification into a detailed plan ready for physical construction. This typically involves a series of steps, moving from high-level abstraction to concrete component selection and layout.

1. Block Diagram Design (Black Box Approach)

The initial design phase focuses on breaking down the overall functionality into manageable blocks without delving into their internal complexities.

• Functional Decomposition: Dividing the complex system into smaller, more manageable functional blocks.
• Black Box Abstraction: Treating each block as a “black box,” focusing solely on its input and output behavior and its overall function within the system. The internal workings of each block are deferred to later stages.
• System-Level Architecture: Defining the overall architecture of the circuit by outlining the interconnection and interaction between these functional blocks.
• Task Distribution: Facilitating team-based design by dividing the overall task into sub-tasks corresponding to the design of individual blocks, which can be tackled in parallel or sequentially.

2. Detailed Block Design and Research

Once the system architecture is defined, each functional block is examined in greater detail, focusing on the electrical functions required and the feasibility of implementation.

• Electrical Function Definition: Specifying the precise electrical functions each block must perform. This involves considering signal processing, amplification, filtering, logic operations, etc.
• Feasibility Research and Mathematical Modeling: Conducting research and using mathematical models to explore different implementation options for each block and assess their feasibility within the given constraints (performance, power, cost, size).
• Technology and Component Exploration: Investigating available electronic components, integrated circuits, and design techniques that can be used to implement the desired functions.
• Trade-off Analysis: Evaluating different design choices and making trade-offs between performance, cost, complexity, and other design parameters.
• Feedback and Iteration: Feeding the results of feasibility research back into earlier design stages. If a block proves difficult or impossible to design within the specified parameters, it might be necessary to adjust the system architecture, modify other blocks, or even revise the overall specification.

3. Component Selection and Layout

The final design stage involves choosing specific components and determining their physical arrangement and connections.

• Component Selection: Choosing individual electronic components (resistors, capacitors, transistors, ICs, etc.) based on their electrical characteristics, performance specifications, availability, cost, and reliability.
• Physical Layout Design: Determining the physical placement of components and the routing of electrical connections. This is crucial for performance, signal integrity, thermal management, and manufacturability.
• Printed Circuit Board (PCB) or Integrated Circuit (IC) Layout: Creating artwork and layout designs suitable for manufacturing PCBs or integrated circuits. PCB layout involves defining the layers, tracks, vias, and component footprints on a circuit board. IC layout involves arranging transistors, interconnects, and other elements within the layers of a semiconductor chip.
• Standardization and Catalog Engineering: Prioritizing the use of standard, readily available components to simplify procurement and reduce costs. “Catalog engineering” refers to leveraging readily available components and pre-designed circuit blocks to solve common, mundane design tasks, allowing designers to focus on more novel and complex aspects of the design.
• Design Constraints and Practical Considerations: Addressing practical constraints such as component availability, lead times, manufacturing tolerances, and cost targets. Balancing ideal component values calculated in earlier stages with commercially available standard values.

4. Design Flow Principles

The overall circuit design process follows a systematic flow, encompassing various key steps:

• Architecture Scope Definition: Clearly defining the overall system architecture and boundaries.
• Materials Selection: Choosing appropriate materials for substrates, components, and interconnects, considering factors like electrical properties, thermal characteristics, mechanical strength, and cost.
• Schematic Capture: Creating a digital schematic diagram of the circuit using EDA software.
• PCB Layout Design: Designing the physical layout of the circuit on a PCB, including component placement, routing, and layer stack-up.
• Power and Signal Integrity Consideration: Analyzing and mitigating potential issues related to power distribution and signal quality. This includes addressing noise, impedance matching, crosstalk, and electromagnetic interference (EMI).
• Test and Validation: Developing and implementing test plans and procedures to verify and validate the functionality and performance of the designed circuit.

Costs in Circuit Design

The cost of circuit design is significantly influenced by the complexity of the circuit being developed.

• Complexity and Design Time: Higher complexity, driven by a larger number of components and innovative design features, directly translates to increased engineering hours and associated costs.
• Engineering Expertise: Circuit design requires highly skilled engineers, and their time is a significant cost factor.
• Minute Details and Iteration: Attention to detail and the iterative nature of the design process, including fine-tuning component parameters and addressing unforeseen issues, can consume substantial time and resources.
• Example: Transistor Size and Codecs: Modifying parameters like transistor sizes in IC design or optimizing codecs in signal processing applications can require significant engineering effort and computational resources, impacting design costs.

Cost Reduction Strategies

• Material Selection: Choosing cost-effective materials can significantly reduce overall costs.
  • Flexible Electronics Example: In flexible electronics, substituting polyimide substrates with materials like PEN (Polyethylene Naphthalate) or PET (Polyethylene Terephthalate) can lead to substantial cost reductions (factors of 5-10) while maintaining acceptable performance for certain applications.
• Additive Manufacturing: Exploring alternative manufacturing methods like additive manufacturing (3D printing) for PCB fabrication.
  • 3D-Printed PCBs: Additive manufacturing techniques for PCBs can potentially reduce material waste and manufacturing steps compared to traditional subtractive manufacturing methods, leading to cost savings and environmental benefits.
• Standardization and Re-use: Utilizing standardized components and pre-designed circuit blocks wherever possible to reduce design effort and component costs.

Design Costs vs. Production Costs

It is important to note that circuit design costs typically far exceed the per-unit production costs, especially for complex and customized circuits. The design effort is a fixed cost, while production costs are variable and depend on the volume of units manufactured. The design quality significantly impacts both the functionality and the production cost of the final circuit.

Verification and Testing: Ensuring Design Integrity

Verification and testing are crucial steps to ensure the designed circuit functions correctly and meets all specifications.

Verification: Design Validation Through Analysis

Verification is a process of systematically examining each stage of the design to confirm that it will perform as intended according to the specification.

• Mathematical Analysis: Applying mathematical principles and techniques to analyze circuit behavior and predict performance characteristics.
• Computer Simulations: Extensive use of simulation software to model and analyze circuit performance under various operating conditions and stress scenarios.
• Error Detection and Correction: Identifying potential design flaws, errors, or inconsistencies through verification processes. This often involves iterative refinement and redesign to address identified issues.
• Large-Scale Simulations: For complex designs, verification may require large-scale computer simulations to accurately model system-level behavior and interactions between different circuit blocks.

Testing: Real-World Performance Evaluation

Testing complements verification by evaluating the physical prototype of the circuit in a real-world environment.

• Prototype Construction: Building a physical prototype of the designed circuit.
• Test Procedures: Following predefined test procedures, often outlined in the specification or as addenda, to systematically evaluate circuit functionality and performance.
• Real-World Performance Assessment: Checking if the physical circuit behaves as predicted by simulations and meets the performance criteria defined in the specification.
• Validation of Verification Results: Testing provides empirical validation of the predictions and analyses performed during the verification stage.
• Iterative Testing and Debugging: Testing often reveals unexpected issues or performance limitations in the physical implementation. This may require iterative testing, debugging, and design modifications to achieve the desired performance.

Design Software: Tools for Efficiency and Accuracy

Design software plays a vital role in modern circuit design, enhancing efficiency, accuracy, and complexity handling.

• Electronic Design Automation (EDA) Software: Specialized software tools used for various stages of circuit design, including schematic capture, simulation, layout, verification, and testing.
• Logic Circuit Implementation: Software can be used to implement logic circuits, such as complement circuits, through program code. Visual DSD (Digital System Design) is an example of software that facilitates this approach.
• Functional Simulation and Verification: EDA tools enable functional simulations to verify the logical correctness of circuit designs and ensure they implement the intended logic functions.
• Hardware Description Languages (HDLs): Languages like VHDL (VHSIC Hardware Description Language) are used to model and describe hardware architectures. HDLs facilitate design abstraction, simulation, and synthesis of digital circuits.
• Efficiency and Cost Reduction: Design software helps create more efficient circuits, potentially reducing component count, power consumption, and manufacturing costs.
• Reliability and Longevity: Software-assisted design can contribute to creating more robust and reliable circuits with improved longevity through optimized designs and thorough verification.

Examples of Design Software

• Altium Designer: A comprehensive PCB design software suite.
• EasyEDA: A web-based EDA tool for schematic capture, circuit simulation, and PCB layout.
• gEDA: A suite of free software tools for electronic design automation.
• KiCad: An open-source EDA software suite for schematic capture and PCB layout.
• OrCAD: A suite of EDA tools for PCB design and simulation.
• NI Multisim: Simulation software for analog, digital, and power electronics circuits.
• SPICE (Simulation Program with Integrated Circuit Emphasis): A widely used analog electronic circuit simulator.

Prototyping: Iterative Refinement and Error Correction

Prototyping is an indispensable iterative process in circuit design, enabling continuous refinement and error correction.

• Iterative Design Process: Circuit design is rarely a linear process. Prototyping facilitates an iterative approach, allowing designers to test, evaluate, and refine their designs in stages.
• Error Detection and Correction: Prototyping is crucial for identifying and correcting errors that may not be apparent during simulation or theoretical analysis.
• Meticulous Attention to Detail: Circuit design demands meticulous attention to detail to minimize errors. Prototyping provides a practical means to validate design choices and catch subtle mistakes.
• Multiple Tests and Validation: Designers conduct multiple tests on prototypes to ensure efficiency, safety, and compliance with specifications before releasing a design for production.
• Safety and Reliability Assurance: Prototyping is particularly critical in electrical work due to safety concerns. It helps ensure the safety of consumers who will use the final products.
• Risk Mitigation: Neglecting prototyping can lead to significant risks, including flawed circuits that may cause fires, overheating, or other hazards.
• Designer Responsibility: Circuit designers bear the responsibility for ensuring the safety and reliability of their designs. Prototyping is a crucial tool for fulfilling this responsibility.
• Consequences of Flawed Circuits: Flawed electrical circuits can pose serious risks, including fires, overheated wires, burns, and severe injuries to users. Prototyping helps mitigate these risks.

Results: From Simulation to Functional Circuit

The circuit design process culminates in a functional electrical circuit that meets the initial specifications.

• Circuit Board Simulator: The process often starts with a circuit board simulator to visualize and virtually test the circuit’s functionality before physical construction.
• Blueprint (Technical Design Drawing): A detailed technical drawing (blueprint) of the final circuit design, serving as a guide for physical assembly.
• Functional Electrical Circuit: The end result is a working electrical circuit, assembled based on the blueprint, ready for its intended application.
• Versatile Applications: Electrical circuits power a vast array of devices, from simple appliances to complex systems like televisions, computers, and industrial machinery.
• Skill and Expertise: Circuit design requires specialized skills and expertise, often acquired through formal education and practical experience.
• Ubiquitous Technology: Electrical circuits are fundamental components of modern technology and are essential in numerous aspects of everyday life.

Documentation: Essential for Commercial Designs

Documentation is a critical component of any commercial circuit design, ensuring clarity, compliance, and maintainability.

• Specification and Testing Procedures: Documentation must include the design specification, outlining the requirements and performance targets, as well as detailed testing procedures used to verify compliance.
• Compliance with Regulations: Commercial designs must comply with relevant industry regulations and standards. Documentation includes a statement of compliance, often in the form of a CE Declaration in the European Union.
• CE Declaration (EU): A declaration listing the European directives that the product complies with and identifying the individual responsible for ensuring compliance.
• Varying Documentation Needs: The extent and type of documentation required depend on the complexity of the circuit, the intended application, and the regulatory requirements of the target market.
• Obsolescence Management: Documentation can also address post-design services, such as managing component obsolescence and facilitating future design revisions or maintenance.

Software

• Altium Designer
• EasyEDA
• gEDA
• KiCad
• OrCAD
• NI Multisim
• SPICE

See also

• Advanced Design System
• Circuit design language
• Configuration design
• Electrical system design
• Electronic circuit design
• Electronic design automation
• Espresso heuristic logic minimizer
• GDSII
• Integrated circuit design
• List of EDA companies
• Mesh analysis
• Open Artwork System Interchange Standard

References

Sources

• “Does Your Design Meet Its Specs? Introduction to Hardware Design Verification | What Is Design Verification?”. InformIT. 19 August 2005.
• Diagram of possible design process
• US guide on CE marking
• UK guide on CE marking
• A beginners tutorial on understanding, analysing, and designing basic electronic circuits
• Vladimir Gurevich Electronic Devices on Discrete Components for Industrial and Power Engineering, CRC Press, London - New York, 2008, 418 p., ISBN 9781420069822